Wollschlaeger v. Florida

ELEVENTH CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS

Court of Appeals Docket #: 12-14009 Docketed: 08/02/2012
Termed: 07/25/2014
Nature of Suit: 3440 Other Civil Rights
Dr. Bernd Wollschlaeger, et al v. Governor State of FL, et al
Appeal From: Southern District of Florida

Summary/Issues: 1A; Suit over constitutionality of a law prohibiting doctors to interrogate patients about gun ownership.

tr>6/16/2016CourtPublic Communication: Court will convene at 8:30 a.m. Tuesday, June 21, 2016.

Filing DateFiling PartyDocument Description
   Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals
2/16/2017 Court Corrected En Banc Opinion
2/16/2017 Court Judgment entered as to Appellants Fred Bearison, Nabil El Sanadi, Trina Espinola, Florida Department of Health, Brigette Rivera Goersch, Governor of the State of Florida, Onelia Lage, Bradley Levine, Donald Mullins, Robert Nuss, James Orr, Jason Rosenberg, Secretary, Florida Agency for Health Care Administration, Secretary, State of Florida, Merle Stringer, Surgeon General, State of Florida, George Thomas, Elisabeth Tucker, M.D., Gary Winchester and Zachariah P. Zachariah.
2/16/2017 CourtEleventh Circuit Court of Appeal Opinion
1/6/2017AmicusNotice to Court
7/26/2016CourtOral Argument CD sent to Karen Gould, Pacific Legal Foundation.
7/25/2016AppellantAppellants Supplemental Letter Brief
7/25/2016AppelleeAppellees Supplemental Letter Brief
7/19/2016Non-PartyOral Argument CD sent to Rachel Bates, Northeastern University Law Library, 400 Huntington Ave 31KN, Boston MA 02115.
7/19/2016Non-PartyNortheastern University Law Library’s Request for Oral Argument CD
7/19/2016Non-PartyOral Argument CD sent to Rachel Nordby PL-01 The Capitol, Tallahassee, FL 32399-1050.
7/15/2016Non-PartyDeputy Solicitor General’s Request for Oral Argument CD in Multiple Cases
7/6/2016Non-PartyOral argument CD requested by Karen Gould, Pacific Legal Foundation.
6/24/2016CourtOral Argument CD sent to Deanna Barkett FitzGerald, Ropes & Gray, Prudential Tower, 800 Boylston Street, Boston MA 02199.
6/24/2016Non-PartyRopes & Gray’s Request for Oral Argument CD
6/23/2016CourtMemorandum to Counsel Directing Parties to Supplemental Briefs Addressing Severability
6/23/2016CourtOral Argument CD sent to Gregorg Curfman, MD, Harvard Health Publications, 10 Shattuck Street, 2nd Floor, Boston, MA 02115.
6/23/2016CourtOral Argument CD sent to Anshu S. Budhrani, Law Clerk to the Honorable Marcia G. Cooke, U.S. District Court, Southern District of Florida, 400 North Miami Avenue, Courtroom 11-2, Miami, Florida 33128 (305-523-5154.
6/21/2016CourtOral argument held. Oral Argument participants were Rachel E. Nordby for Appellants Florida Department of Health, Secretary, State of Florida, Secretary, Florida Agency for Health Care Administration, Elisabeth Tucker, M.D., Governor of the State of Florida, George Thomas, Jason Rosenberg, Zachariah P. Zachariah, Trina Espinola, Merle Stringer, James Orr, Gary Winchester, Nabil El Sanadi, Robert Nuss, Onelia Lage, Fred Bearison, Donald Mullins, Brigette Rivera Goersch, Bradley Levine and Surgeon General, State of Florida and Douglas Hallward-Driemeier for Appellees American Academy of Pediatrics, Bernd Wollschlaeger, Judith Schaechter, Tommy Schechtman, American Academy of Family Physicians, American College of Physicians, Florida Chapter, Inc., Roland Gutierrez, Stanley Sack and Shannon Fox-Levine.
6/21/2016Non-PartyHarvard Health Publications Request for Oral Argument CD
6/16/2016CourtPublic Communication: Court will convene at 8:30 a.m. Tuesday, June 21, 2016.
6/15/2016AppelleeNotice of Supplemental Authority re Free Speech Coalition, Inc. v. Attorney General of the United States, No. 13-3681 (3d Cir. June 8, 2016)
5/25/2016AmicusE-filed Appearance of Counsel processed for Attorney David H. Fry for Amicus Curiae Law Center to Prevent Gun Violence in 12-14009.
5/25/2016AmicusE-filed Appearance of Counsel processed for Attorney Juliana Mariko Yee for Amicus Curiae Law Center to Prevent Gun Violence in 12-14009.
5/25/2016AmicusAPPEARANCE of Counsel Form filed by David H. Fry for Law Center to Prevent Gun Violence.
5/25/2016AmicusAPPEARANCE of Counsel Form filed by Juliana Mariko Yee for Law Center to Prevent Gun Violence.
5/24/2016AmicusAmicus Brief filed by Amicus Curiae Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense. Service date: 04/27/2016 email – Attorney for Appellants: Nordby, Osterhaus, Vail; Attorney for Appellees: Goetz, Hallward-Driemeier, Lowy, Mullins.
5/23/2016AmicusEn Banc Brief of Amicus Curiae The America Professional Society on the Abuse of Children in Support of Plaintiffs-Appellees and Affirmance
5/23/2016AmicusEn Banc Brief of Amicus Curiae Institute for Justice in Support of Appellees
5/23/2016AmicusEn Banc Brief of Amici Curiae American Health Association et al In Support of Appellees and Affirmance
5/23/2016AmicusEn Banc Brief of American Bar Association as Amicus Curiae In Support of Plaintiffs-Appellees Dr. Bernd Wollschlaeger et al. and Affiramance
5/23/2016AmicusAmicus Curiae En Banc Brief of the Thomas Jefferson Center for the Protection of Free Expression In Support of Plaintiffs-Appellees
5/23/2016AmicusEn Banc Brief Amicus Curiae of Pacific Legal Foundation In Support of Plaintiffs-Appellees and for Affirmance
5/23/2016AmicusEn Banc Brief of Amicus Curiae The America Professional Society on the Abuse of Children in Support of Plaintiffs-Appellees and Affirmance
5/23/2016AmicusEn Banc Brief of Amicus Curaie Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense In America In Support of Plaintiffs-Appellees And Affirmance
5/23/2016AmicusAmicus Curiae En Banc Brief of ACLU Foundation Florida et al In Support of Plaintiffs-Appellees and Affirmance
5/23/2016CourtORDER: Motion for leave to file amicus brief is GRANTED. [ # 7765079-2 ], Motion for leave to file amicus brief is GRANTED. [ # 7764784-2 ], Motion for leave to file amicus brief is GRANTED. [ # 7764748-2 ], Motion for leave to file amicus brief is GRANTED. [ # 7764180-2 ], Motion for leave to file amicus brief is GRANTED. [ # 7763947-2 ], Motion for leave to file amicus brief is GRANTED. [ # 7763760-2 ], Motion for leave to file amicus brief is GRANTED. [ # 7763672-2 ], Motion for leave to file amicus brief is GRANTED. [ # 7763367-2 ], Motion for leave to file amicus brief is GRANTED.
5/23/2016CourtORDER: Motion to appear pro hac vice filed by Juliana Mariko Yee and David H. Fry is GRANTED.
5/20/2016AppelleeAppearance of Counsel Form for Appellees Attorney Deanna B. FitzGerald
5/20/2016CourtOral argument scheduled. Argument Date: Tuesday, 06/21/2016 Argument Location:
5/20/2016CourtAttorney Douglas Hallward-Driemeier for Appellees American Academy of Pediatrics, Bernd Wollschlaeger, Judith Schaechter, Tommy Schechtman, American Academy of Family Physicians, American College of Physicians, Florida Chapter, Inc., Roland Gutierrez, Stanley Sack and Shannon Fox-Levine hereby acknowledges receipt of a copy of the printed calendar for 06/21/2016. Douglas H. Hallward-Driemeier 202-508-4776 will present argument.
5/20/2016CourtAttorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellants Florida Department of Health, Secretary, State of Florida, Secretary, Florida Agency for Health Care Administration, Elisabeth Tucker, M.D., Governor of the State of Florida, George Thomas, Jason Rosenberg, Zachariah P. Zachariah, Trina Espinola, Merle Stringer, James Orr, Gary Winchester, Nabil El Sanadi, Robert Nuss, Onelia Lage, Fred Bearison, Donald Mullins, Brigette Rivera Goersch, Bradley Levine and Surgeon General, State of Florida hereby acknowledges receipt of a copy of the printed calendar for 06/21/2016. Rachel Nordby 850-414-3684 will present argument.
5/20/2016CourtNotice of Oral Argument
5/12/2016CourtReceived paper copies of EBrief filed by Appellants Governor of the State of Florida, et al.
5/11/2016AppellantEn Banc Reply Brief of Appellants
4/28/2016Court E-filed Appearance of Counsel processed for Attorney Leonard Martin Reeder Jr. for Not Party The Thomas Jefferson Center for the Protection of Free Expression in 12-14009.
4/27/2016AmicusAmicus Curiae En Banc Brief of the Thomas Jefferson Center for the Protection of Free Expression In Support of Appeellees
4/27/2016AmicusMotion of the Thomas Jefferson Center for the Protection of Free Expression for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Brief In Support of Appellees
4/27/2016CourtAPPEARANCE of Counsel Form filed by L. Martin Reeder, Jr. for The Thomas Jefferson Center for the Protection of Free Expression (ECF: Leonard Reeder)
4/27/2016AmicusEn Banc of Amicus Curiae Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense in America In Support of Plaintiffs-Appellees and Affirmance
4/27/2016AmicusUnopposed Motion of Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense In America for Leave to File En Banc Brief Amicus Curiae
4/27/2016AmicusEn Banc Brief of American Bar Association as Amicus Curiae In Support of Plaintiffs-Appellees Dr. Bernd Wollschlaeger et al and Affirmance
4/27/2016AmicusAmerican Bar Association’s Motion for Leave to File En Banc Brief as Amicus Curiae In Support of Plaintiffs-Appellees Dr. Bernd Wollschlaeger et al and Affirmance
4/27/2016CourtReceived paper copies of EBrief filed by Appellees Bernd Wollschlaeger, et al.
4/27/2016AmicusEn Banc Brief of American Bar Association as Amicus Curiae In Support of Plaintiffs-Appellees Dr. Bernd Wollschlaeger et al and Affirmance
4/27/2016AmicusAmerican Bar Association’s Motion for Leave to File En Banc Brief as Amicus Curiae In Support of Plaintiffs-Appellees Dr. Bernd Wollschlaeger et al and Affirmance
4/27/2016AmicusEn Banc Brief of Amicus Curiae The America Professional Society on the Abuse of Children In Support of Plaintiffs-Appellees and Affirmance
4/27/2016AmicusMotion for Leave to File En Banc Brief of Amicus Curiae The America Professional Society on the Abuse of Children In Support of Plaintiffs-Appellees and Affirmance
4/26/2016AppelleeAddendum to En Banc Brief for Appellees Dr. Benrnd Wollschlaeger, et al.
4/26/2016AppelleeEn Banc Brief for Appellees Dr. Benrnd Wollschlaeger, et al.
4/26/2016AmicusEn Banc Brief of Amicus Curiae Institute for Justice in Support of Appellees
4/26/2016AmicusMotion for Leave to file En Banc Brief of Amicus Curiae Institute for Justice in Support of Appellees
4/26/2016AmicusE-filed Appearance of Counsel processed for Attorney Justin Samuel Wales for Amicus Curiae American Bar Association in 12-14009.
4/26/2016CourtAdded Attorney(s) Justin Samuel Wales for party(s) Amicus Curiae American Bar Association, in case 12-14009.
4/26/2016AmicusBrief Amicus Curiae of American Medical Association, American Academy of Pediatrics et al In Support of Plaintiffs-Appellees at the Rehearing En Banc and Urging Affirmance
4/26/2016AmicusMotion of American Medical Association, American Academy of Pediatrics et al For Leave to File Amicus Brief In Support of Plaintiffs-Appellees at the Rehearing En Banc
4/26/2016AmicusAPPEARANCE of Counsel Form filed by Justin S. Wales for American Bar Association (ECF: Justin Wales)
4/26/2016AmicusE-filed Appearance of Counsel processed for Attorney David J. Weiner for Not Party American Professional Society on the Abuse of Children in 12-14009.
4/26/2016AmicusE-filed Appearance of Counsel processed for Attorney Ari Simon Bargil for Amicus Curiae Institute of Justice in 12-14009.
4/26/2016CourtAdded Attorney(s) Ari Simon Bargil for party(s) Amicus Curiae Institute of Justice, in case 12-14009.
4/26/2016AmicusAmicus Curiae En Banc Brief of ACLU Foundation of Florida et al In Support of Plaintiffs-Appellees and Affirmance
4/26/2016AmicusMotion of ACLU Foundation of Florida et al for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Brief In Support of Plaintiffs-Appellees in En Banc Proceeding
4/26/2016CourtE-filed Appearance of Counsel processed for Attorney Charlotte Taylor for Amicus Curiae Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense in 12-14009.
4/26/2016AmicusAPPEARANCE of Counsel Form filed by David J. Weiner for The American Professional Society on the Abuse of Children (ECF: David Weiner)
4/26/2016AmicusAPPEARANCE of Counsel Form filed by Ari Bargil, Amicus Curiae Institute for Justice (ECF: Ari Bargil)
4/26/2016AmicusEn Banc Brief Amicus Curiae of Pacific Legal Foundation In Support of Plaintiffs-Appellees and for Affirmance
4/26/2016AmicusMotion for Leave to File En Banc Brief Amicus Curiae of Pacific Legal Foundation In Support of Plaintiffs-Appellees and for Affirmance
4/22/2016AmicusEn Banc Brief of Amici Curiae National Rifle Association of America, Inc. In Support of Appellants and Reversal
4/22/2016AmicusEn Banc Brief of Amicus United Sportsmen of Florida, Inc., Supporting Appellants and Reversal
4/22/2016AmicusEn Banc Brief of Amici Curiae Second Amendment Foundation and Citizens Committee for the Right to Keep and Bear Arms Supporting Appellants and Reversal
4/22/2016CourrtOrder Granting Motion to File Amicus Briefs
4/22/2016CourtAdded Attorney(s) David H. Fry, Juliana Mariko Yee for party(s) Amicus Curiae Law Center to Prevent Gun Violence, in case 12-14009.
4/21/2016AmicusMOTION to appear pro hac vice filed by David H. Fry for Amicus Curiae Law Center to Prevent Gun Violence and Juliana Mariko Yee for Amicus Curiae Law Center to Prevent Gun Violence.
4/14/2016CourtOrder Granting Motion to Withdraw as Counsel for State Appellants
4/13/2016AmicusE-filed Appearance of Counsel processed for Attorney Deborah J. La Fetra for Not Party Pacific Legal Foundation in 12-14009, Attorney Caleb R. Trotter for Not Party Pacific Legal Foundation in 12-14009.
4/13/2016CourtAdded Attorney(s) Caleb R. Trotter for party(s) Not Party Pacific Legal Foundation, in case 12-14009.
4/12/2016AmicusAPPEARANCE of Counsel Form filed by Caleb R. Trotter for Pacific Legal Foundation, Amicus Curiae
4/12/2016AmicusAPPEARANCE of Counsel Form filed by Deborah J. La Fetra for Pacific Legal Foundation, Amicus Curiae
3/28/2016AmicusEn Banc Brief of Amicus Curiae National Rifle Association of America, Inc. In Support of Appellants and Reversal
3/28/2016AmicusUnopposed Motion of the National Rifle Association of America, Inc. for Leave to File En Banc Amicus Brief in Support of Appellants and Reversal
3/24/2016CourtE-filed Appearance of Counsel processed for Attorney Jordan E. Pratt for Appellant Zachariah P. Zachariah in 12-14009, Attorney Jordan E. Pratt for Appellant Gary Winchester in 12-14009, Attorney Jordan E. Pratt for Appellant Elisabeth Tucker in 12-14009, Attorney Jordan E. Pratt for Appellant George Thomas in 12-14009, Attorney Jordan E. Pratt for Appellant Surgeon General, State of Florida in 12-14009, Attorney Jordan E. Pratt for Appellant Merle Stringer in 12-14009, Attorney Jordan E. Pratt for Appellant Secretary, State of Florida in 12-14009, Attorney Jordan E. Pratt for Appellant Secretary, Florida Agency for Health Care Administration in 12-14009, Attorney Jordan E. Pratt for Appellant Jason Rosenberg in 12-14009, Attorney Jordan E. Pratt for Appellant James Orr in 12-14009, Attorney Jordan E. Pratt for Appellant Robert Nuss in 12-14009, Attorney Jordan E. Pratt for Appellant Donald Mullins in 12-14009, Attorney Jordan E. Pratt for Appellant Bradley Levine in 12-14009, Attorney Jordan E. Pratt for Appellant Onelia Lage in 12-14009, Attorney Jordan E. Pratt for Appellant Governor of the State of Florida in 12-14009, Attorney Jordan E. Pratt for Appellant Brigette Rivera Goersch in 12-14009, Attorney Jordan E. Pratt for Appellant Florida Department of Health in 12-14009, Attorney Jordan E. Pratt for Appellant Trina Espinola in 12-14009, Attorney Jordan E. Pratt for Appellant Nabil El Sanadi in 12-14009, Attorney Jordan E. Pratt for Appellant Fred Bearison in 12-14009.
3/24/2016CourtAdded Attorney(s) Jordan E. Pratt for party(s) Appellant Trina Espinola Appellant Governor of the State of Florida Appellant Secretary, Florida Agency for Health Care Administration Appellant Florida Department of Health Appellant James Orr Appellant Elisabeth Tucker Appellant Merle Stringer Appellant Nabil El Sanadi Appellant Bradley Levine Appellant Surgeon General, State of Florida Appellant Jason Rosenberg Appellant Gary Winchester Appellant Fred Bearison Appellant Onelia Lage Appellant George Thomas Appellant Brigette Rivera Goersch Appellant Donald Mullins Appellant Zachariah P. Zachariah Appellant Secretary, State of Florida Appellant Robert Nuss, in case 12-14009.-
3/24/2016AmicusEn Banc Brief of Amicus Curiae Unified Sportsmen of Florida, Inc. Supporting Appellants and Reversal
3/24/2016AmicusMotion for Leave to File En Banc Brief of Amicus Curiae Unified Sportsmen of Florida, Inc. Supporting Appellants and Reversal
3/24/2016AppellantAppearance of Counsel for Attorney Jordan E. Pratt on Behalf of Governor, State of Florida, et al.
3/24/2016AmicusEn Banc Brief of Amici Curiae Second Amendment Foundation and Citizens Committee for the Right to Keep and Bear Arms Supporting Appellants and Reversal
3/23/2016CourtE-filed Appearance of Counsel processed for Attorney Joseph Gary Samuel Greenlee for Not Party Second Amendment Foundation and Citizens Committee in 12-14009.
3/23/2016CourtE-filed Appearance of Counsel processed for Attorney Stephen Porter Halbrook for Not Party Unified Sportsmen of Florida, Inc. in 12-14009.
3/22/2016AmicusCertificate of Interested Persons and Corporate Disclosure Statement of Amici Second Amendment Foundation and Citizens Committee for the Right to Keep and Bear Arms
3/22/2016AmicusAppearance of Counsel for Attorney Joseph Greenlee on Behalf of Second Amendment Foundation and Citizens Committee
3/22/2016AmicusCertificate of Interested Persons and Corporate Disclosure Statement on Behalf of Unified Sportsmen of Florida, Inc.
3/22/2016AmicusAppearance of Counsel for Attorney Stephen P. Halbrook on Behalf of Unified Sportsmen of Florida, Inc.
3/11/2016AppellantMotion of Allen Winsor to Withdraw as Counsel for State Appellants
3/2/2016CourtE-filed Appearance of Counsel processed for Attorney Denise Mayo Harle for Appellant Zachariah P. Zachariah in 12-14009, Attorney Denise Mayo Harle for Appellant Gary Winchester in 12-14009, Attorney Denise Mayo Harle for Appellant Elisabeth Tucker in 12-14009, Attorney Denise Mayo Harle for Appellant George Thomas in 12-14009, Attorney Denise Mayo Harle for Appellant Surgeon General, State of Florida in 12-14009, Attorney Denise Mayo Harle for Appellant Merle Stringer in 12-14009, Attorney Denise Mayo Harle for Appellant Secretary, State of Florida in 12-14009, Attorney Denise Mayo Harle for Appellant Secretary, Florida Agency for Health Care Administration in 12-14009, Attorney Denise Mayo Harle for Appellant Jason Rosenberg in 12-14009, Attorney Denise Mayo Harle for Appellant James Orr in 12-14009, Attorney Denise Mayo Harle for Appellant Robert Nuss in 12-14009, Attorney Denise Mayo Harle for Appellant Donald Mullins in 12-14009, Attorney Denise Mayo Harle for Appellant Bradley Levine in 12-14009, Attorney Denise Mayo Harle for Appellant Onelia Lage in 12-14009, Attorney Denise Mayo Harle for Appellant Governor of the State of Florida in 12-14009, Attorney Denise Mayo Harle for Appellant Brigette Rivera Goersch in 12-14009, Attorney Denise Mayo Harle for Appellant Florida Department of Health in 12-14009, Attorney Denise Mayo Harle for Appellant Trina Espinola in 12-14009, Attorney Denise Mayo Harle for Appellant Nabil El Sanadi in 12-14009, Attorney Denise Mayo Harle for Appellant Fred Bearison in 12-14009.
3/2/2016CourtAdded Attorney(s) Denise Mayo Harle for party(s) Appellant Trina Espinola Appellant Governor of the State of Florida Appellant Secretary, Florida Agency for Health Care Administration Appellant Florida Department of Health Appellant James Orr Appellant Elisabeth Tucker Appellant Merle Stringer Appellant Nabil El Sanadi Appellant Bradley Levine Appellant Surgeon General, State of Florida Appellant Jason Rosenberg Appellant Gary Winchester Appellant Fred Bearison Appellant Onelia Lage Appellant George Thomas Appellant Brigette Rivera Goersch Appellant Donald Mullins Appellant Zachariah P. Zachariah Appellant Secretary, State of Florida Appellant Robert Nuss, in case 12-14009.
3/2/2016CourtE-filed Appearance of Counsel processed for Attorney Jonathan L. Williams for Appellant Zachariah P. Zachariah in 12-14009, Attorney Jonathan L. Williams for Appellant Gary Winchester in 12-14009, Attorney Jonathan L. Williams for Appellant Elisabeth Tucker in 12-14009, Attorney Jonathan L. Williams for Appellant George Thomas in 12-14009, Attorney Jonathan L. Williams for Appellant Surgeon General, State of Florida in 12-14009, Attorney Jonathan L. Williams for Appellant Merle Stringer in 12-14009, Attorney Jonathan L. Williams for Appellant Secretary, State of Florida in 12-14009, Attorney Jonathan L. Williams for Appellant Secretary, Florida Agency for Health Care Administration in 12-14009, Attorney Jonathan L. Williams for Appellant Jason Rosenberg in 12-14009, Attorney Jonathan L. Williams for Appellant James Orr in 12-14009, Attorney Jonathan L. Williams for Appellant Robert Nuss in 12-14009, Attorney Jonathan L. Williams for Appellant Donald Mullins in 12-14009, Attorney Jonathan L. Williams for Appellant Bradley Levine in 12-14009, Attorney Jonathan L. Williams for Appellant Onelia Lage in 12-14009, Attorney Jonathan L. Williams for Appellant Governor of the State of Florida in 12-14009, Attorney Jonathan L. Williams for Appellant Brigette Rivera Goersch in 12-14009, Attorney Jonathan L. Williams for Appellant Florida Department of Health in 12-14009, Attorney Jonathan L. Williams for Appellant Trina Espinola in 12-14009, Attorney Jonathan L. Williams for Appellant Nabil El Sanadi in 12-14009, Attorney Jonathan L. Williams for Appellant Fred Bearison in 12-14009.
3/2/2016CourtAdded Attorney(s) Jonathan L. Williams for party(s) Appellant Trina Espinola Appellant Governor of the State of Florida Appellant Secretary, Florida Agency for Health Care Administration Appellant Florida Department of Health Appellant James Orr Appellant Elisabeth Tucker Appellant Merle Stringer Appellant Nabil El Sanadi Appellant Bradley Levine Appellant Surgeon General, State of Florida Appellant Jason Rosenberg Appellant Gary Winchester Appellant Fred Bearison Appellant Onelia Lage Appellant George Thomas Appellant Brigette Rivera Goersch Appellant Donald Mullins Appellant Zachariah P. Zachariah Appellant Secretary, State of Florida Appellant Robert Nuss, in case 12-14009.
3/2/2016CourtE-filed Appearance of Counsel processed for Attorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellant Zachariah P. Zachariah in 12-14009, Attorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellant Gary Winchester in 12-14009, Attorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellant Elisabeth Tucker in 12-14009, Attorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellant George Thomas in 12-14009, Attorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellant Surgeon General, State of Florida in 12-14009, Attorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellant Merle Stringer in 12-14009, Attorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellant Secretary, State of Florida in 12-14009, Attorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellant Secretary, Florida Agency for Health Care Administration in 12-14009, Attorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellant Jason Rosenberg in 12-14009, Attorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellant James Orr in 12-14009, Attorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellant Robert Nuss in 12-14009, Attorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellant Donald Mullins in 12-14009, Attorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellant Bradley Levine in 12-14009, Attorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellant Onelia Lage in 12-14009, Attorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellant Governor of the State of Florida in 12-14009, Attorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellant Brigette Rivera Goersch in 12-14009, Attorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellant Florida Department of Health in 12-14009, Attorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellant Trina Espinola in 12-14009, Attorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellant Nabil El Sanadi in 12-14009, Attorney Rachel E. Nordby for Appellant Fred Bearison in 12-14009.
3/2/2016CourtAdded Attorney(s) Rachel E. Nordby for party(s) Appellant Trina Espinola Appellant Governor of the State of Florida Appellant Secretary, Florida Agency for Health Care Administration Appellant Florida Department of Health Appellant James Orr Appellant Elisabeth Tucker Appellant Merle Stringer Appellant Nabil El Sanadi Appellant Bradley Levine Appellant Surgeon General, State of Florida Appellant Jason Rosenberg Appellant Gary Winchester Appellant Fred Bearison Appellant Onelia Lage Appellant George Thomas Appellant Brigette Rivera Goersch Appellant Donald Mullins Appellant Zachariah P. Zachariah Appellant Secretary, State of Florida Appellant Robert Nuss, in case 12-14009.
3/2/2016AppellantAppellants Appearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Denise Harle
3/2/2016AppellantAppellants Appearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Jonathan L. Williams
3/2/2016AppellantAppellants Appearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Rachel Nordby
2/29/2016CourtE-filed Appearance of Counsel processed for Attorney Richard D. Batchelder Jr. for Appellee Bernd Wollschlaeger in 12-14009, Attorney Richard D. Batchelder Jr. for Appellee Tommy Schechtman in 12-14009, Attorney Richard D. Batchelder Jr. for Appellee Judith Schaechter in 12-14009, Attorney Richard D. Batchelder Jr. for Appellee Stanley Sack in 12-14009, Attorney Richard D. Batchelder Jr. for Appellee Roland Gutierrez in 12-14009, Attorney Richard D. Batchelder Jr. for Appellee Shannon Fox-Levine in 12-14009, Attorney Richard D. Batchelder Jr. for Appellee American College of Physicians, Florida Chapter, Inc. in 12-14009, Attorney Richard D. Batchelder Jr. for Appellee American Academy of Pediatrics in 12-14009, Attorney Richard D. Batchelder Jr. for Appellee American Academy of Family Physicians in 12-14009, Attorney Mariel Goetz for Appellee Bernd Wollschlaeger in 12-14009, Attorney Mariel Goetz for Appellee Tommy Schechtman in 12-14009, Attorney Mariel Goetz for Appellee Judith Schaechter in 12-14009, Attorney Mariel Goetz for Appellee Stanley Sack in 12-14009, Attorney Mariel Goetz for Appellee Roland Gutierrez in 12-14009, Attorney Mariel Goetz for Appellee Shannon Fox-Levine in 12-14009, Attorney Mariel Goetz for Appellee American College of Physicians, Florida Chapter, Inc. in 12-14009, Attorney Mariel Goetz for Appellee American Academy of Pediatrics in 12-14009, Attorney Mariel Goetz for Appellee American Academy of Family Physicians in 12-14009, Attorney Alexandra Roth for Appellee Bernd Wollschlaeger in 12-14009, Attorney Alexandra Roth for Appellee Tommy Schechtman in 12-14009, Attorney Alexandra Roth for Appellee Judith Schaechter in 12-14009, Attorney Alexandra Roth for Appellee Stanley Sack in 12-14009, Attorney Alexandra Roth for Appellee Roland Gutierrez in 12-14009, Attorney Alexandra Roth for Appellee Shannon Fox-Levine in 12-14009, Attorney Alexandra Roth for Appellee American College of Physicians, Florida Chapter, Inc. in 12-14009, Attorney Alexandra Roth for Appellee American Academy of Pediatrics in 12-14009, Attorney Alexandra Roth for Appellee American Academy of Family Physicians in 12-14009.
2/26/2016AppelleeAppellees Appearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Alexandra Roth
2/26/2016AppelleeAppellees Appearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Mariel Goetz
2/26/2016AppelleeAppellees Appearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Richard D. Batchelder
2/26/2016CourtEn Banc Briefing Notice to Parties
2/5/2016CourtMemorandum to Counsel or Parties re Motions for Leave to File Amicus Brief as Moot
2/3/2016CourtOrder Granting Petition for Rehearing
2/3/2016CourtMemorandum to Counsel or Parties
1/22/2016AmicusCertificate of Interested Persons and Corporate Disclosure Statement by Amicus Curiae American Medical Association et al.
1/21/2016AmicusCertificate of Interested Persons and Corporate Disclosure Statement by Amicus Curiae Institute for Justice
1/14/2016AmicusBrief of American Bar Association as Amicus Curiae
1/14/2016AmicusAmerican Bar Association’s Motion for Leave to File Brief as Amicus Curiae In Support of Petition for Rehearing En Banc
1/14/2016AmicusBrief Amicus Curiae of Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense In America In Support of Petition for Rehearing En Banc
1/14/2016AmicusUnopposed Motion for Leave to File Brief Amicus Curiae of Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense In America In Support of Petition for Rehearing En Banc
1/14/2016AmicusAmicus Brief of ACLU Foundation of Florida, Inc. et al.
1/14/2016AmicusMotion of ACLU Foundation of Florida et al for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Brief In Support of Petition for Rehearing En Banc
1/14/2016AmicusAPPEARANCE of Counsel Form filed by Charlotte H. Taylor for Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense in America
1/14/2016AmicusBrief of Amicus Curiae Institute for Justice In Support of The Petition for Rehearing En Banc
1/14/2016AmicusMotion for Leave to File Brief of Amicus Curiae In Support of Petitioners’ Petition for Rehearing En Banc
1/13/2016AmicusBrief Amicus Curiae of American Medical Association et al
1/13/20106AmicusMotion of American Medical Association, American Academy of Pediatrics et al for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Brief In Support of 2016 Petition for Rehearing En Banc
1/4/2016PetitionerPetition for Rehearing En BancExhibit A to Petition for Rehearing En BancExhibit B to Petition for Rehearing En BancExhibit C to Petition for Rehearing En Banc
12/14/2015AmiciBrief Amicus Curiae of American Medical Association et al In Support of Appellees 2015 Petition for Rehearing En Banc
12/14/2015AmiciMotion of American Medical Association, American Academy of Pediatrics et al for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Brief In Support of 2015 Petition for Rehearing En Banc
12/14/2015CourtPanel rehearing opinion of 07/28/2015 VACATED and new opinion issued.
12/14/2015CourtPublished Opinion
12/14/2015CourtNotice to Counsel and Parties
12/14/2015CourtJudgment entered as to Appellants Fred Bearison, Nabil El Sanadi, Trina Espinola, Florida Department of Health, Brigette Rivera Goersch, Governor of the State of Florida, Onelia Lage, Bradley Levine, Donald Mullins, Robert Nuss, James Orr, Jason Rosenberg, Secretary, Florida Agency for Health Care Administration, Secretary, State of Florida, Merle Stringer, Surgeon General, State of Florida, George Thomas, Elisabeth Tucker, M.D., Gary Winchester and Zachariah P. Zachariah.
11/23/2015AppelleeAppellees Citation of Supplemental Authorities re Dana’s Railroad Supply v. Florida Case No. 14-14426
10/1/2015AppellantAppellants’ Memorandum Addressing The Impact of Reed v. Town of Gilbert, Arizona
10/1/2015AppelleeAppellees’ Submission Requested By The Court
9/15/2015CourtAdded Attorney(s) J. Adam Skaggs for party(s) Amicus Curiae Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense, in case 12-14009.
9/15/2015CourtAdded Attorney(s) Peter Canfield for party(s) Amicus Curiae Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense, in case 12-14009.
9/15/2015CourtAdded Attorney(s) Gregory Andrew Castanias for party(s) Amicus Curiae Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense, in case 12-14009.
9/15/2015CourtAdded Attorney(s) Michael David Sloan for party(s) Amicus Curiae American Bar Association, in case 12-14009.
9/11/2015CourtCourt Order Requesting Memorandum Whether Reed v. Town of Gilbert Arizona Necessitates Application of Strict Scrutiny
9/10/2015AppelleeAppellees’ Reply to Opposition to Motion to Stay The Mandate Pending Petition for Certiorari If Rehearing En Banc Is Not Granted
8/31/2015AppellantAppellants’ Opposition to Motion to Stay the Mandate Pending Petition for Certioarari if Rehearing En Banc Is Not Granted
8/28/2015AmicusBrief of Amicus Curiae of Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense In America In Support of Petition for Rehearing En Banc
8/28/2015AmicusUnopposed Motion for Leave to File Brief Amicus Curiae of Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense In America In Support of Petition for Rehearing En Banc
8/28/2015AmicusAPPEARANCE of Counsel Form filed by J. Adam Skaggs for Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense in America (ECF: Gregory Castanias)
8/28/2015AmicusAPPEARANCE of Counsel Form filed by Peter C. Canfield for Moms Demand Gun Sense in America (ECF: Gregory Castanias)
8/28/2015AmicusAPPEARANCE of Counsel Form filed by Gregory A. Castanias for Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense in America (ECF: Gregory Castanias)
8/28/2015AmicusAmicus Curiea Brief of ACLU Foundation of Florida et al In Support of Petition for Rehearing En Banc
8/28/2015AmicusMotion of ACLU Foundation of Florida et al for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Brief In Support of Petition for Rehearing En Banc
8/28/2015AmicusAPPEARANCE of Counsel Form filed by Michael D. Sloan – Amicus Curiae, American Bar Association (ECF: Michael Sloan)
8/28/2015AmicusAdded Attorney(s) Paulette Brown for party(s) Amicus Curiae American Bar Association, in case 12-14009.
8/28/2015AmicusAPPEARANCE of Counsel Form filed by Nancy G. Abudu, ACLU Foundation of Florida, Inc. (ECF: Nancy Abudu)
8/28/2015AmicusBrief of the American Bar Association As Amicus Curiae In Support of Petition for Rehearing En Banc
8/28/2015AmicusAmerican Bar Association’s Motion for Leave to File Brief as Amicus Curiae In Support of Petition for Rehearing En Banc
8/28/2015Amicus APPEARANCE of Counsel Form filed by Paulette Brown, Amicus Curiae, American Bar Association (ECF: Paulette Brown)
8/28/2015AmicusBrief Amicus Curiae of American Medical Association, American Academy of Pediatrics et al. In Support of Appellees 2015 Petition for Rehearing En Banc
8/28/2015AmicusMotion of American Medical Association, American Academy of Pediatrics et al. for Leave to File Amicus Brief In Support of 2015 Petition for Rehearing En Banc
8/18/2015AppelleeAppellees’ Motion to Stay The Mandate Pending Petition for Certiorari Rehearing En Banc Is Not Granted
8/18/2015Petitioners Petition for Rehearing En Banc
7/28/2015CourtORDER: On it’s own motion, the Court GRANTS panel rehearing.. Panel opinion of 7/25/14 vacated by court. See 7/28/15 rehearing opinion [7535016-1]–[Edited 07/29/2015 by ES]
7/28/2015CourtJudgment entered as to Appellants Fred Bearison, Nabil El Sanadi, Trina Espinola, Florida Department of Health, Brigette Rivera Goersch, Governor of the State of Florida, Bradley Levine, Donald Mullins, Robert Nuss, James Orr, Jason Rosenberg, Secretary, Florida Agency for Health Care Administration, Secretary, State of Florida, Merle Stringer, Surgeon General, State of Florida, George Thomas, Elisabeth Tucker, M.D., Gary Winchester and Zachariah P. Zachariah.
7/28/2015CourtOpinion on Petition for Rehearing
3/25/2015AppellantAppellants Response to Appellees Notice of Supplemental Authority re Stuart v. Camnitz, 744 F.3d 238 (4th Cir. 2014)
1/22/2015AppelleeNotice of Supplemental Authority re Stuart v. Camnitz, No. 14-1150 (Dec. 22, 2014)
11/4/2014AmicusBrief of Amicus Curiae Institute for Justice in Support of the Petition for Rehearing En Banc
11/4/2014AmicusBrief of the American Bar Association as Amicus Curiae in Support of Petition for Rehearing En Banc
11/4/2014AmicusBrief Amicus Curiae of American Medical Association, American Academy of Pediatrics, et al In Support of Petition for Rehearing En Banc
11/4/2014AmicusAmicus Brief of ACLU Foundation of Fla., Inc. Alachua County Medical Society, et al. In Support of Petition for Rehearing En Banc
11/4/2014CourtOrder Granting Motions for Leave to file Amicus Briefs 
10/6/2014CourtAdded Attorney(s) Richard J. Ovelmen for party(s) Amicus Curiae American Bar Association, in case 12-14009.
10/2/2014CourtAdded Attorney(s) William C. Hubbard for party(s) Amicus Curiae American Bar Association, in case 12-14009.
9/15/2014AppelleeNotice of Supplemental Authority King v. Governor of State of New Jersey, No. 13-4429 (3d Cir. Sept. 11, 2014)
8/28/2014CourtAdded Attorney(s) Maria Kayanan for party(s) Amicus Curiae Broward County Pediatric Society Amicus Curiae ACLU Foundation of Florida, Inc. Amicus Curiae Alachua County Medical Society Amicus Curiae Broward County Medical Association, in case 12-14009.
8/25/2014AmicusAmerican Bar Association’s Motion for Leave to File Brief as Amicus Curiae in Support of Petition for Rehearing En Banc
8/25/2014AmicusMotion for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Brief in Support of Petition for Rehearing En Banc of Plaintiffs-Appellees
8/25/2014AmicusMotion of American Medical Association, American Academy of Pediatrics, American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry et al for Leave to File Amicus Brief
8/25/2014Court*ERROR*Amicus brief filed in support of rehearing petition by leave of court by Richard Levenstein for American Osteopathic Association; American College PhysiciansAmicus Curium American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, American Academy of Family Physicians, American Academy of Pediatrics, American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, American College of Surgeons, American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists and American Medical Association.–[Edited 08/25/2014 by DHC] (ECF: Richard Levenstein)
8/25/2014AmicusAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Maria Kayanan
8/22/2014AmicusAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney William C. Hubbard
8/22/2014AmicusAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Richard J. Ovelmen
8/18/2014CourtReceived paper copies of E-PFR filed by Appellants Fred Bearison, Nabil El Sanadi, Trina Espinola, Florida Department of Health, Brigette Rivera Goersch, Governor of the State of Florida, Onelia Lage, Bradley Levine, Donald Mullins, Robert Nuss, James Orr, Jason Rosenberg, Secretary, Florida Agency for Health Care Administration, Secretary, State of Florida, Merle Stringer, Surgeon General, State of Florida, George Thomas, Elisabeth Tucker, M.D., Gary Winchester and Zachariah P. Zachariah.
8/18/2014AmicusMotion for Leave to File of Amicus Curiae in Support of the Petition for Rehearing en Banc
8/18/2014AmicusAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Paul M. Sherman
8/15/2014AppellantPetition for Rehearing En Banc
7/25/2014CourtJudgment entered as to Appellants Fred Bearison, Nabil El Sanadi, Trina Espinola, Florida Department of Health, Brigette Rivera Goersch, Governor of the State of Florida, Onelia Lage, Bradley Levine, Donald Mullins, Robert Nuss, James Orr, Jason Rosenberg, Secretary, Florida Agency for Health Care Administration, Secretary, State of Florida, Merle Stringer, Surgeon General, State of Florida, George Thomas, Elisabeth Tucker, M.D., Gary Winchester and Zachariah P. Zachariah.
7/25/2014CourtOpinion
7/3/2014AppelleeNotice of Supplemental Authority re McCullen v. Coakley, No. 12-1168
6/26/2014CourtOral Argument CD sent to law clerk Enjoliqe Aytch.
6/20/2014AppelleeNotice of Supplemental Authority re Susan B. Anthony List v. Driehaus, No. 13-193 (U.S. June 16, 2014)
6/12/2014AmicusNotice of Supplemental Authority Law Review Article re Physicians Firearms and Free Expression Reconciling First Amendment Theory with Doctrinal Analysis
5/7/2014CourtE-filed Appearance of Counsel processed for Attorney Jamie Zysk Isani for Amicus Curiae University of Miami School of Law Children and Youth Clinic in 12-14009, Attorney Jamie Zysk Isani for Amicus Curiae Palm Beach County Medical Society in 12-14009, Attorney Jamie Zysk Isani for Amicus Curiae Florida Public Health Association in 12-14009, Attorney Jamie Zysk Isani for Amicus Curiae Early Childhood Initiative Foundation in 12-14009, Attorney Jamie Zysk Isani for Amicus Curiae Children’s Healthcare Is a Legal Duty, Inc. in 12-14009, Attorney Jamie Zysk Isani for Amicus Curiae Center on Children & Families in 12-14009, Attorney Jamie Zysk Isani for Amicus Curiae Broward County Pediatric Society in 12-14009, Attorney Jamie Zysk Isani for Amicus Curiae Broward County Medical Association in 12-14009, Attorney Jamie Zysk Isani for Amicus Curiae Alachua County Medical Society in 12-14009, Attorney Jamie Zysk Isani for Amicus Curiae ACLU Foundation of Florida, Inc. in 12-14009, Attorney Thomas Richard Julin for Amicus Curiae University of Miami School of Law Children and Youth Clinic in 12-14009, Attorney Thomas Richard Julin for Amicus Curiae Palm Beach County Medical Society in 12-14009, Attorney Thomas Richard Julin for Amicus Curiae Florida Public Health Association in 12-14009, Attorney Thomas Richard Julin for Amicus Curiae Early Childhood Initiative Foundation in 12-14009, Attorney Thomas Richard Julin for Amicus Curiae Children’s Healthcare Is a Legal Duty, Inc. in 12-14009, Attorney Thomas Richard Julin for Amicus Curiae Center on Children & Families in 12-14009, Attorney Thomas Richard Julin for Amicus Curiae Broward County Pediatric Society in 12-14009, Attorney Thomas Richard Julin for Amicus Curiae Broward County Medical Association in 12-14009, Attorney Thomas Richard Julin for Amicus Curiae Broward County Medical Association in 12-14009, Attorney Thomas Richard Julin for Amicus Curiae Alachua County Medical Society in 12-14009, Attorney Thomas Richard Julin for Amicus Curiae ACLU Foundation of Florida, Inc. in 12-14009, Attorney Randall C. Marshall for Amicus Curiae University of Miami School of Law Children and Youth Clinic in 12-14009, Attorney Randall C. Marshall for Amicus Curiae Palm Beach County Medical Society in 12-14009, Attorney Randall C. Marshall for Amicus Curiae Florida Public Health Association in 12-14009, Attorney Randall C. Marshall for Amicus Curiae Early Childhood Initiative Foundation in 12-14009, Attorney Randall C. Marshall for Amicus Curiae Children’s Healthcare Is a Legal Duty, Inc. in 12-14009, Attorney Randall C. Marshall for Amicus Curiae Center on Children & Families in 12-14009, Attorney Randall C. Marshall for Amicus Curiae Broward County Pediatric Society in 12-14009, Attorney Randall C. Marshall for Amicus Curiae Broward County Medical Association in 12-14009, Attorney Randall C. Marshall for Amicus Curiae Alachua County Medical Society in 12-14009, Attorney Randall C. Marshall for Amicus Curiae ACLU Foundation of Florida, Inc. in 12-14009, Attorney Gordon McRae Mead Jr. for Amicus Curiae University of Miami School of Law Children and Youth Clinic in 12-14009, Attorney Gordon McRae Mead Jr. for Amicus Curiae Palm Beach County Medical Society in 12-14009, Attorney Gordon McRae Mead Jr. for Amicus Curiae Florida Public Health Association in 12-14009, Attorney Gordon McRae Mead Jr. for Amicus Curiae Early Childhood Initiative Foundation in 12-14009, Attorney Gordon McRae Mead Jr. for Amicus Curiae Children’s Healthcare Is a Legal Duty, Inc. in 12-14009, Attorney Gordon McRae Mead Jr. for Amicus Curiae Center on Children & Families in 12-14009, Attorney Gordon McRae Mead Jr. for Amicus Curiae Broward County Pediatric Society in 12-14009, Attorney Gordon McRae Mead Jr. for Amicus Curiae Broward County Medical Association in 12-14009, Attorney Gordon McRae Mead Jr. for Amicus Curiae Alachua County Medical Society in 12-14009, Attorney Gordon McRae Mead Jr. for Amicus Curiae ACLU Foundation of Florida, Inc. in 12-14009.
5/7/2014CourtE-filed Appearance of Counsel processed for Attorney Randall C. Marshall for Amicus Curiae University of Miami School of Law Children and Youth Clinic in 12-14009, Attorney Randall C. Marshall for Amicus Curiae Palm Beach County Medical Society in 12-14009, Attorney Randall C. Marshall for Amicus Curiae Florida Public Health Association in 12-14009, Attorney Randall C. Marshall for Amicus Curiae Early Childhood Initiative Foundation in 12-14009, Attorney Randall C. Marshall for Amicus Curiae Children’s Healthcare Is a Legal Duty, Inc. in 12-14009, Attorney Randall C. Marshall for Amicus Curiae Broward County Pediatric Society in 12-14009, Attorney Randall C. Marshall for Amicus Curiae Alachua County Medical Society in 12-14009, Attorney Randall C. Marshall for Amicus Curiae ACLU Foundation of Florida, Inc. in 12-14009.
10/24/2013AppelleeResponse to Notice of Supplemental Authority re Pickup v. Brown, — F.3d –, 2013 WL 4564249 (9th Cir. Aug. 29, 2013)
9/11/2013AppellantNotice of Supplemental Authority re Pickup v. Brown, — F.3d –, 2013 WL 4564249 (9th Cir. Aug. 29, 2013)
8/8/2013AppelleeAppellants Response to Appellees Notice of Supplemental Authority
8/7/2013CourtOral Argument CD sent to Edward M. Mullins for American Academy of Pediatrics, Bernd Wollschlaeger, Judith Schaechter, Tommy Schechtman, American Academy of Family Physicians, American College of Physicians, Florida Chapter, Inc., Roland Gutierrez, Stanley Sack and Shannon Fox-Levine.
8/6/2013AppellantRequest for Oral Argument CD
7/31/2013AppelleeAppellees Response to Supplemental Authority
7/24/2013CourtOral Argument CD sent to Katerina Kariolis Paralegal Cooper & Kirk 1523 New Hampshire Ave NW Washington, D.C. 20036 202-220-9647.
7/22/2013AppellantRequest for Oral Argument CD
7/19/2013AppelleeSupplemental Notice of Supplemental Authority re Agency for Int’l Dev. v. Alliance for Open Society Int’l, No. 12-10 (June 20, 2013
7/18/2013CourtOral argument held. Oral Argument participants were Allen C. Winsor for Appellant Governor of the State of Florida and Douglas Hallward-Driemeier for Appellees American Academy of Pediatrics, Bernd Wollschlaeger, Judith Schaechter, Tommy Schechtman, American Academy of Family Physicians, American College of Physicians, Florida Chapter, Inc., Roland Gutierrez, Stanley Sack and Shannon Fox-Levine.
7/3/2013CourtOrder Granting Motion for Substitution of Attorney Allen Windsor
7/2/2013AppelleeNotice of Supplemental Authority re Clapper v. Amnesty International, USA__S.Ct.__,2013 WL 673253 (2013)
7/2/2013CourtOrder Granting Motion to Substitute Appearance of Counsel
6/14/2013AppellantMotion for Leave to Substitute Counsel
6/14/2013AppellantMotion Appearance of Counsel Form Construed as Motion to Appear in Oral Argument
6/14/2013CourtE-filed Appearance of Counsel processed for Attorney Allen C. Winsor for Appellant Governor of the State of Florida in 12-14009.
6/14/2013CourtAdded Attorney(s) Allen C. Winsor for party(s) Appellant Governor of the State of Florida, in case 12-14009.
6/14/2013AppellantAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Allen C. Winsor
5/22/2013CourtOral argument scheduled. Argument Date: Thursday, 07/18/2013 Argument Location: Miami, FL.
3/22/2013AppelleeAppellees Response to Notice of Supplemental Authority re Clapper v. Amnesty International, USA__S.Ct.__,2013 WL 673253 (2013)
3/7/2013AppellantNotice of Supplemental Authority re Clapper v. Amnesty International, USA__S.Ct.__,2013 WL 673253 (2013)
3/4/2013AppelleeAppellees Response to Notice of Supplemental Authority re Gun Violence Reduction Executive Actions,
2/19/2013AppellantNotice of Supplemental Authority re Gun Violence Reduction Executive Actions,
2/14/2013CourtAssigned to Tentative Calendar for Week of July 15, 2013
2/4/2013CourtAssigned to Tentative Calendar for Week of May 20, 2013
1/15/2013CourtOrder Granting Motion for Leave to File Amicus Brief by American Medical Association et al
12/27/2012AmicusMotion for Leave for American Osteopathic Association to Join Amicus Curiae for Academy Medical Association, American Academy of Pediatrics et al
12/27/2012CourtDOCKETED IN ERROR. Motion for Leave to File Amicus Brief filed by Leave of Court by Amicus Curiae American Medical Association. Service date: 11/05/2012 US mail – District Judge Cooke; Attorney for Amicus Curiae: Heckenlively; Attorney for Appellant: Bondi; Attorney for Appellees: Kainen, Lewis, Lowy, Lucas, Ripa, Vice; email – Originating Clerk/Ag Larimore; Attorney for Amicus Curium: Caso, Cooper, Isani, Julin, Levenstein, Marshall, Mead, Patterson, Thompson; Attorney for Appellants: Osterhaus, Vail; Attorney for Appellees: Hallward-Driemeier, Manheim, Mullins; Attorney for Not Party: Greenberg. (ECF: Richard Levenstein)
12/11/2012AppellantCertificate of Readiness and Transmittal of Record on Appeal
12/11/2012CourtRecord on Appeal filed. Pleadings, 5 volumes; Transcript, 1 volumes; Exhibit Folder, 1 volumes
12/5/2012CourtPAPER COPIES Amicus Brief filed by Amicus Curiae American Association of Suicidology. Service date: 11/05/2012 email – Attorney for Amicus Curium: Caso, Cooper, Isani, Julin, Levenstein, Marshall, Mead, Patterson, Thompson; Attorney for Appellants: Osterhaus, Vail; Attorney for Appellees: Hallward-Driemeier, Manheim, Mullins; Attorney for Not Party: Greenberg; US mail – Attorney for Amicus Curiae: Heckenlively; Attorney for Appellant: Bondi; Attorney for Appellees: Kainen, Lewis, Lowy, Lucas, Ripa, Vice.
11/21/2012CourtAmicus Brief filed by Amicus Curiae American Association of Suicidology. Service date: 11/05/2012 email – Attorney for Amicus Curium: Caso, Cooper, Isani, Julin, Levenstein, Marshall, Mead, Patterson, Thompson; Attorney for Appellants: Osterhaus, Vail; Attorney for Appellees: Hallward-Driemeier, Manheim, Mullins; Attorney for Not Party: Greenberg; US mail – Attorney for Amicus Curiae: Heckenlively; Attorney for Appellant: Bondi; Attorney for Appellees: Kainen, Lewis, Lowy, Lucas, Ripa, Vice.
11/21/2012CourtReceived paper copies of REPLY EBrief filed by Appellants Fred Bearison, Nabil El Sanadi, Trina Espinola, Florida Department of Health, Brigette Rivera Goersch, Governor of the State of Florida, Onelia Lage, Bradley Levine, Donald Mullins, Robert Nuss, James Orr, Jason Rosenberg, Secretary, Florida Agency for Health Care Administration, Secretary, State of Florida, Merle Stringer, Surgeon General, State of Florida, George Thomas, Elisabeth Tucker, M.D., Gary Winchester and Zachariah P. Zachariah.
11/20/2012AppellantAppellants’ Reply Brief
11/15/2012CourtNotice of Deficient Amicus Brief Filed By ACLU
11/15/2012CourtOrder Motion for Leave to File Amicus Brief Moot
11/9/2012CourtReceived paper copies of EBrief filed by Amicus Curiae American Medical Association, et al.
11/9/2012CourtE-filed Appearance of Counsel filed by Attorney Richard Harry Levenstein for Amicus Curiae American Medical Association in 12-14009 processed.
11/9/2012CourtAdded Attorney(s) Jamie Zysk Isani, Randall C. Marshall for party(s) Amicus Curiae ACLU Foundation of Florida, Inc., et al., in case 12-14009.
11/9/2012CourtAdded Attorney(s) Gordon McRae Mead Jr. for party(s) Amicus Curiae ACLU Foundation of Florida, Inc., et al., in case 12-14009.
11/8/2012CourtUnopposed Over the phone extension granted by clerk. Updated Reply Brief. Due on 11/20/2012 as to Appellant Secretary, State of Florida.
11/6/2012AmicusReceived paper copies of EBrief filed by Amicus Curiae ACLU Foundation of Florida, Inc., et al..
11/5/2012AmicusAmicus Curiae Brief in Support of Affirming the Judgment for Plaintiffs-Appellees of the ACLU Foundation of Florida, Inc. et al
11/5/2012AmicusBrief of Amici Curiae American Health Association, American Association of Suicidology et al
11/5/2012AmicusMotion for Leave to File Amicus Brief of Amici Curiae American Public Health Association, American Association of Suicidology et al.
11/5/2012AmicusBrief Amicus Curiae for American Medical Association, American Academy of Pediatrics, American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry et al
11/2/2012AmicusAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Richard H. Levenstein
11/2/2012AmicusAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Gordon M. Mead
11/2/2012AmicusAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Randall C. Marshall
11/1/2012CourtE-filed Appearance of Counsel filed by Attorney Gerald Edward Greenberg for Not Party Service in 12-14009 processed.
11/1/2012AmicusAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Jamie Zysk Isani
11/1/2012AmicusAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Gerald E. Greenberg
10/31/2012AmicusAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Thomas R. Julin
10/31/2012AmicusAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Bryan H. Heckenlively
10/31/2012AmicusAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Justin S. Weinstein-Tull
10/29/2012CourtReceived paper copies of EBrief filed by Appellees American Academy of Family Physicians, American Academy of Pediatrics, American College of Physicians, Florida Chapter, Inc., Shannon Fox-Levine, Roland Gutierrez, Stanley Sack, Judith Schaechter and Tommy Schechtman.
10/29/2012AppelleeBrief for Appellees Dr. Bernd Wollschlaeger
10/25/2012CourtOrder Granting Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice for Attorney Bryan H. Heckenlively
10/15/2012CourtMOTION to appear pro hac vice filed by Attorney Bryan H. Heckenlively for Amicus Curiae Law Center to Prevent Gun Violence, et al.. [6701151-1]
10/10/2012CourtOver the phone extension granted by clerk. Appellee’s Brief due on 10/29/2012 as to Appellee American Academy of Family Physicians..
10/1/2012AmicusBrief of Amicus Curiae National Rifle Association of America, Inc. Supporting Appellants and Reversal
10/1/2012CourtAdded Attorney(s) Charles J. Cooper, David H. Thompson, Peter A. Patterson for party(s) Amicus Curiae National Rifle Association of America, Inc., in case 12-14009.
9/27/2012CourtReceived paper copies of EBrief filed by Amicus Curiae National Rifle Association of America, Inc..
9/25/2012CourtReceived paper copies of EBrief filed by Amicus Curium Center for Constitutional Jurisprudence and Doctors for Responsible Gun Ownership.
9/24/2012AmicusBrief of Amici Curiae Center for Constitutional Jurisprudence Doctors for Responsible Gun Ownership in Support of Defendants-Appellants
9/24/2012CourtE-filed Appearance of Counsel filed by Attorney Anthony T. Caso for Amicus Curiae Doctors for Responsible Gun Ownership in 12-14009, Attorney Anthony T. Caso for Amicus Curiae Center for Constitutional Jurisprudence in 12-14009 processed.
9/21/2012AmicusAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Anthony T. Caso
9/20/2012AmicusAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Peter A. Patterson
9/20/2012AmicusAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney David H. Thompson
9/20/2012AmicusAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Charles J. Cooper
9/18/2012CourtAppellant’s brief filed by Fred Bearison, Nabil El Sanadi, Trina Espinola, Florida Department of Health, Brigette Rivera Goersch, Governor of the State of Florida, Onelia Lage, Bradley Levine, Donald Mullins, Robert Nuss, James Orr, Jason Rosenberg, Secretary, Florida Agency for Health Care Administration, Secretary, State of Florida, Merle Stringer, Surgeon General, State of Florida, George Thomas, Elisabeth Tucker, M.D., Gary Winchester and Zachariah P. Zachariah. Service date: 09/17/2012 [12-14009] Attorney for Appellee: Kainen – US mail; Attorney for Appellee: Lucas – US mail; Attorney for Appellee: Mullins – US mail; Attorney for Appellee: Ripa – US mail; Attorney for Appellee: Vice – US mail.
9/18/2012CourtRecord Excerpts filed by Appellant Florida Department of Health. Service date: 09/17/2012 US mail – Attorney for Appellees: Kainen, Lucas, Mullins, Ripa, Vice.
9/17/2012AppellantBrief for Appellants
9/5/2012AppellantCivil Appeal Statement
9/5/2012CourtOrder Granting Motion for Leave to File Civil Appeal Statement
9/5/2012AppellantMotion to File Civil Appeals Statement Out of Time
9/4/2012CourtOver the phone extension granted by clerk. Appellants brief due on 09/18/2012 as to Appellant Governor of the State of Florida. The motion was unopposed.
8/30/2012CourtCourt Notification to Appellee’s Counsel to File Civil Appeal Statement
8/21/2012CourtAdded Attorney(s) Timothy David Osterhaus for party(s) Appellant Trina Espinola Appellant Zachariah P. Zachariah Appellant James Orr Appellant Florida Department of Health Appellant George Thomas Appellant Secretary, Florida Agency for Health Care Administration Appellant Surgeon General, State of Florida Appellant Gary Winchester Appellant Jason Rosenberg Appellant Robert Nuss Appellant Donald Mullins Appellant Fred Bearison Appellant Merle Stringer Appellant Nabil El Sanadi Appellant Onelia Lage Appellant Elisabeth Tucker Appellant Bradley Levine Appellant Governor of the State of Florida Appellant Secretary, State of Florida Appellant Brigette Rivera Goersch, in case 12-14009.
8/20/2012AppellantAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Timothy D. Osterhaus
8/16/2012CourtE-filed Appearance of Counsel filed by Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Governor of the State of Florida in 12-14009 processed.
8/16/2012CourtE-filed Appearance of Counsel filed by Attorney Douglas Hallward-Driemeier for Appellee Bernd Wollschlaeger in 12-14009, Attorney Douglas Hallward-Driemeier for Appellee Tommy Schechtman in 12-14009, Attorney Douglas Hallward-Driemeier for Appellee Judith Schaechter in 12-14009, Attorney Douglas Hallward-Driemeier for Appellee Stanley Sack in 12-14009, Attorney Douglas Hallward-Driemeier for Appellee Roland Gutierrez in 12-14009, Attorney Douglas Hallward-Driemeier for Appellee Shannon Fox-Levine in 12-14009, Attorney Douglas Hallward-Driemeier for Appellee American College of Physicians, Florida Chapter, Inc. in 12-14009, Attorney Douglas Hallward-Driemeier for Appellee American Academy of Pediatrics in 12-14009, Attorney Douglas Hallward-Driemeier for Appellee American Academy of Family Physicians in 12-14009, Attorney Bruce S. Manheim Jr. for Appellee Bernd Wollschlaeger in 12-14009, Attorney Bruce S. Manheim Jr. for Appellee Tommy Schechtman in 12-14009, Attorney Bruce S. Manheim Jr. for Appellee Judith Schaechter in 12-14009, Attorney Bruce S. Manheim Jr. for Appellee Stanley Sack in 12-14009, Attorney Bruce S. Manheim Jr. for Appellee Roland Gutierrez in 12-14009, Attorney Bruce S. Manheim Jr. for Appellee Shannon Fox-Levine in 12-14009, Attorney Bruce S. Manheim Jr. for Appellee American College of Physicians, Florida Chapter, Inc. in 12-14009, Attorney Bruce S. Manheim Jr. for Appellee American Academy of Pediatrics in 12-14009, Attorney Bruce S. Manheim Jr. for Appellee American Academy of Family Physicians in 12-14009 processed.
8/16/2012CourtAdded Attorney(s) Bruce S. Manheim Jr., Douglas Hallward-Driemeier for party(s) Appellee Shannon Fox-Levine Appellee Stanley Sack Appellee Roland Gutierrez, in case 12-14009.
8/16/2012AppelleeAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Bruce Manheim
8/16/2012AppelleeAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Douglas H. Hallward Driemeier
8/8/2012CourtE-filed Appearance of Counsel filed by Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Zachariah P. Zachariah in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Gary Winchester in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Elisabeth Tucker in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant George Thomas in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Surgeon General, State of Florida in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Merle Stringer in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Secretary, State of Florida in 12-14009 processed.
8/8/2012CourtE-filed Appearance of Counsel filed by Attorney Edward M. Mullins for all Appellees in 12-14009 processed. E-filed Appearance of Counsel filed by Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Gary Winchester in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Elisabeth Tucker in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant George Thomas in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Surgeon General, State of Florida in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Merle Stringer in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Secretary, State of Florida in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Secretary, Florida Agency for Health Care Administration in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Jason Rosenberg in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant James Orr in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Robert Nuss in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Donald Mullins in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Bradley Levine in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Onelia Lage in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Governor of the State of Florida in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Brigette Rivera Goersch in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Florida Department of Health in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Trina Espinola in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Nabil El Sanadi in 12-14009, Attorney Jason Vail for Appellant Fred Bearison in 12-14009 processed
8/8/2012AppellantCertificate of Interested Persons
8/8/2012AppellantAppearance of Counsel Form for Attorney Jason Vail
8/7/2012CourtThe Transcript Order Form is not required as to Appellant Governor of the State of Florida, et al. There are no hearings to be transcribed / all transcripts are on file.
8/2/2012AppellantNotice of Appeal
  USDC Southern District of Florida
9/3/2013CourtPAPERLESS ORDER staying 119 Plaintiffs’ Verified Motion to Recover Attorneys’ Fees and Costs; staying 125 Motion to Exceed Page Limits; and staying 129 Motion to Exceed Page Limits in light of 117 Omnibus Order staying resolution of the fee motion pending the outcome of the 108 Notice of Appeal. For further details, see 117 Omnibus Order. Signed by Magistrate Judge William C. Turnoff on 9/3/13. (lml)
2/7/2013PlaintiffMotion to Exceed Page Limits to Reply in Support of Verified Motion to Recover Attorneys Fees
2/7/2013PlaintiffPlaintiffs’ Reply in Support of Their Verified Motion to Recover Attorneys’ Fees and Costs
1/18/2013CourtAcknowledgment of Receipt of Certificate of Readiness and Transmittal of Record on Appeal
1/8/2013DefendantDefendants’ Response in Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Attorneys’ Fees
1/8/2013DefendantMotion to Exceed Page Limits to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Attorneys’ Fees
12/7/2012CourtENDORSED ORDER granting 123 Joint Motion for Extension of Time regarding the deadlines to file response/reply to pending fee motion. Defendants shall have an additional 30 days to file their response; and Plaintiffs shall have 30 days after the filing of a response within which to file a reply. Signed by Magistrate Judge William C. Turnoff on 12/7/12. (lml)
12/7/2012PlaintiffJoint Motion for Enlargement of Time
12/5/2012CourtCertified and Transmitted Record on Appeal to US Court of Appeals (Atlanta Office) consisting of (5)Volumes of Pleadings, (1)Volume of Transcripts and (1)Accordion folder containing DE# 63 with CD; re 109 Notice of Appeal. USCA# 12-14009-FF (mc)
12/5/2012PlaintiffCertificate of Readiness and Transmittal of Record on Appeal
11/30/2012CourtENDORSED ORDER referring Motion to the Honorable William C. Turnoff for report and recommendation: 119 MOTION for Attorney Fees filed by Bernd Wollschlaeger. Signed by Judge Marcia G. Cooke on 11/30/2012. (af00)
11/30/2012PlaintiffPlaintiffs’ Verified Motion to Recover Attorneys’ Fees and Costs and Accompanying Memorandum of Law
11/6/2012CourtAttorney Augustine Ripa terminated. Notice of Termination delivered by US Mail to Augustine Ripa. (ls)(per DE #118)
11/6/2012PlaintiffNotice of Withdrawal of Counsel for Plaintiffs
8/21/2012CourtOmnibus Order
8/9/2012CourtClerks Notice to Filer re 115 MOTION for Extension of Time for attorney conference per LR 7.3 Motion with Multiple Reliefs Filed as One Relief; ERROR – The Filer selected only one relief event and failed to select the additional corresponding events for each relief requested in the motion. The docket entry was corrected by the Clerk. It is not necessary to refile this document but future filings must comply with the instructions in the CM/ECF Attorney User’s Manual. (ls)
8/9/2012DefendantJoint Motion for Enlargement of Time and Motion for Stay of Execution of Judgment for Attorneys’ Fees and Costs
8/8/2012PlaintiffTranscript Order Form
8/7/2012CourtAcknowledgment of Receipt of Notice of Appeal
8/1/2012PlaintiffNotice of and Accompanying Memorandum in Support of Plaintiffs’ Bill of Costs
7/30/2012CourtTransmission of Notice of Appeal, Judgment, Order and Docket Sheet to US Court of Appeals re 109 Notice of Appeal (mc)
7/30/2012CourtClerks Notice to Filer re 108 Notice (Other). Wrong Event Selected; ERROR – The Filer selected the wrong event. The document was re-docketed by the Clerk, see de# 109. It is not necessary to refile this document. (mc)
7/30/2012CourtAppeal Fees Received
7/30/2012CourtNotice of Appeal (See DE# 108 for image) by Fred Bearison, Kurt S. Browning, Elizabeth Dudek, Nabil El Sanadi, Trina Espinola, Frank Farmer, Onelia Lage, Bradley Levine, Donald Mullins, Robert Nuss, James Orr, Brigitte Rivera Goersch, Jason Rosenberg, Rick Scott, Merle Stringer, George Thomas, Elisabeth Tucker, Gary Winchester, Zachariah P. Zachariah; re 106 Judgment, 105 Order on Motion for Summary Judgment. Filing fee $ 455.00 Receipt#: FLS100042882. Within fourteen days of the filing date of a Notice of Appeal, the appellant must complete the Eleventh Circuit Transcript Order Form regardless of whether transcripts are being ordered [Pursuant to FRAP 10(b)]. For information go to our FLSD website under Transcript Information. (mc)
7/30/2012PlaintiffNotice of Appeal
7/30/2012DefendantNotice of Appearance of Defendants Attorney Jason Vail
7/2/2012CourtFinal Judgment
6/29/2012CourtOmnibus Order on Cross Motions for Summary Judgment
2/10/2012CourtAttorney Douglas J. Giuliano terminated. (ls)(per DE #104)
2/10/2012PlaintiffNotice of Withdrawal of Counsel for Plaintiffs Counsel Douglas J. Giuliano
12/9/2011DefendantDefendants’ Reply to Plaintiffs’ Response to Defendants’ Motion for Summary Judgment
12/5/2011PlaintiffReply to Defendants’ Response to Plaintiffs’ Supplemental Statement of Undisputed Facts
12/5/2011PlaintiffPlaintiffs’ Reply to Defendants’ Response to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment
12/1/2011PlaintiffPlaintiffs’ Opposition to Defendants’ Statement of Undisputed Facts
12/1/2011PlaintiffPlaintiffs’ Opposition to Defendants’ Motion for Summary Judgment and Accompanying Memorandum of Law
11/23/2011DefendantDefendants’ Response to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment
11/14/2011CourtENDORSED ORDER denying as moot 92 Defendants’ Amended Motion for Summary Judgment, in light of 93 Second Amended Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Judge Marcia G. Cooke on 11/14/2011. (scy)
11/14/2011CourtENDORSED ORDER denying as moot 90 Defendants’ Motion for Summary Judgment, in light of 93 Second Amended Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Judge Marcia G. Cooke on 11/14/2011. (scy)
11/14/2011CourtENDORSED ORDER granting 91 Defendants’ Motion for Leave to Exceed Page Limit. Signed by Judge Marcia G. Cooke on 11/14/2011. (scy)
11/14/2011DefendantNotice of Filing Statement of Material Facts
11/14/2011DefendantDefendants’ Second Amended Motion for Summary Judgment
11/14/2011DefendantDefendants’ Amended Motion for Summary Judgment
11/14/2011DefendantDefendants’ Motion to Exceed the Page Limit
11/14/2011DefendantDefendants’ Motion for Summary Judgment
11/14/2011CourtENDORSED ORDER granting nunc pro tunc 85 Motion for Leave to File Excess Pages. Signed by Judge Marcia G. Cooke on 11/14/2011. (scy)
11/11/2011PlaintiffPlaintiffs’ Supplemental Statement of Undisputed Facts in Support of Cross Motions for Summary Judgment
11/11/2011PlaintiffJoint Statement of Undisputed Facts In Support of Cross Motions for Summary Judgment
11/11/2011PlaintiffPlaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment and Accompanying Memorandum of Law
11/10/2011PlaintiffUnopposed Motion for Enlargement of Page Limit for Joint Statement of Undisputed Facts
10/25/2011CourtENDORSED ORDER granting 83 Plaintiffs’ Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time. The parties shall file their motions for summary judgment and joint statement of facts on or before November 11, 2011. Signed by Judge Marcia G. Cooke on 10/25/2011. (scy)
10/25/2011PlaintiffPlaintiffs’ Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Simultaneous Motions for Summary Judgment and or To Revise Scheduling Report
10/4/2011DefendantAnswer to First Amended Complaint
9/21/2011PlaintiffJoint Scheduling Report
9/14/2011CourtOrder Granting Plaintiffs’ Motion for Preliminary Injunction
9/14/2011CourtORDER denying 75 Defendants’ Motion to Strike Portions of Plaintiffs’ Supplemental Memorandum and Motion for Leave to File Reply. Defendants failed to comply with Local Rule 7.1(A)(3), which requires counsel to confer in good faith before filing any motions other than those specifically exempt. The parties should take very seriously their obligations under Local Rule 7.1(A)(3) to confer in good faith in an attempt to resolve issues prior to seeking judicial intervention. Moreover, Plaintiffs’ memorandum did not improperly exceed the scope of an acceptable supplemental brief. Plaintiffs provided additional information in support of arguments they made in their prior motions and at the hearing before me. The only “new argument” Plaintiffs raised was a rebuttal of a new argument Defendants set forth in their own supplemental memorandum. Striking the Plaintiffs memorandum is not warranted. I also find these issues have been fully briefed and additional argument is unnecessary. Signed by Judge Marcia G. Cooke on 9/14/2011. (scy)
8/15/2011PlaintiffOpposition to Defendants’ Objection-Motion to Strike Portions of Plaintiffs’ Supplemental Memorandum and Alternative Motion for Leave to Respond
8/10/2011CourtENDORSED ORDER granting 76 Joint Motion for Extension of Time to File Joint Scheduling Report. The parties shall file a Joint Scheduling Report within five days of this Court’s decision on Plaintiffs’ Motion for Preliminary Injunction. Signed by Judge Marcia G. Cooke on 8/10/2011. (scy)
8/8/2011PlaintiffParties’ Joint and Unopposed Motion to Enlarge Time to File Joint Scheduling Order
7/27/2011DefendantDefendants’ Objection-Motion to Strike Portions of Plaintiff’s Supplemental Memorandum and Alternative Motion for Leave to Respond
7/22/2011DefendantDefendants’ Response In Opposition to Request of ACLU to File Amicus
7/19/2011PlaintiffPlaintiffs’ Supplemental Memorandum In Support of Their Motion for A Preliminary Injunction
7/19/2011AmicusNotice of Attorney Appearance for Amici Curiae Civil Liberties Union of Florida, Inc.
7/19/2011DefendantDefendants’ Supplemental Response to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Preliminary Injunction
7/19/2011CourtENDORSED ORDER granting 67 Motion for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Memorandum in Support of the Plaintiffs’ Motion for Preliminary Injunction. Signed by Judge Marcia G. Cooke on 7/19/2011. (scy)
7/19/2011AmicusNotice of Appearance for Attorney Gordon M. Mead
7/19/2011AmicusNotice of Appearance for Attorney Gerald E. Greenberg
7/19/2011AmicusMotion for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Memorandum in Support of the Plaintiffs’ Motion for Preliminary Injunction
715/2011CourtOrder Granting Motion for Charles J. Cooper, David H. Thompson, Brian S. Koukoutchos, and Peter A. Patterson to Appear Pro Hac Vice
7/14/2011CourtTranscript of Evidentiary Hearing Held on July 13th, 2011
7/13/2011CourtPaperless Minute Entry for proceedings held before Judge Marcia G. Cooke: Evidentiary Hearing held on 7/13/2011. All counsel present. Court Reporter: Judy Shelton, 305-523-5294 / Judy_Shelton@flsd.uscourts.gov (im)
7/11/2011PlaintiffPlaintiffs’ Notice of Conventional Filing
7/11/2011CourtAmended Order Denying National Rifle Association’s Motion to Intervene
7/11/2011CourtOrder Granting Motion for Order Directing Clerk to Change Case Style
7/11/2011PlaintiffPlaintiffs’ Response to Defendants’ Motion for an Order Directing the Clerk to Change the Style of the Case
7/11/2011CourtOrder Vacating 55 Order on Motion to Intervene. Signed by Judge Marcia G. Cooke on 7/11/2011.
7/8/2011PlaintiffPlaintiffs’ Reply Memorandum In Support of Their Motion for A Preliminary Injunction
7/8/2011CourtENDORSED ORDER granting in part and denying in part 50 Motion for Leave to Participate as Amicus Curiae. The National Rifle Association’s motion for leave to file an amicus brief is granted. The National Rifle Association’s motion to participate in the July 13, 2011 hearing is denied. This Court will take into consideration the NRA’s arguments, as set forth in their brief. Signed by Judge Marcia G. Cooke on 7/8/2011.
7/8/2011DefendantMotion for an Order Directing the Clerk to Change the Style of the Case
7/8/2011CourtOrder Denying National Rifle Association’s Motion to Intervene
7/7/2011CourtENDORSED ORDER granting 53 Unopposed Motion for Leave to File Excess Pages. Plaintiffs may file a Consolidated Reply in support of their Motion for Preliminary Injunction not to exceed 15 pages in length. Signed by Judge Marcia G. Cooke on 7/7/2011.
7/7/2011PlaintiffPlaintiffs’ Unopposed Motion for Leave to Exceed Page Limitation as to Their Consolidated Reply to the Opposition Filed With the National Rifle Association’s
7/5/2011PlaintiffPlaintiffs’ Response to the National Rifle Association’s Motion for Leave to Participate as Amicus Curiae
7/5/2011IntervenorProposed Intervenor National Rifle Association’s Reply Memorandum in Support of Its Motion to Intervene
7/5/2011IntervenorProposed Intervenor National Rifle Association’s Motion for Leave to Participate as Amicus Curiae and Incorporated Memorandum of Law
7/5/2011DefendantResponse of Defendants to Motion for Preliminary Injunction
7/1/2011PlaintiffPlaintiffs’ Opposition to the National Rifle Association’s Motion to Intervene
6/30/2011CourtOrder Granting Motion for Bruce Manheim et al to Appear Pro Hac Vice
6/30/2011CourtOrder Granting Motions for Jonathan E. Lowy, Esq., and Daniel R. Vice to Appear Pro Hac Vice
6/28/2011DefendantDefendants’ Response to NRA’s Motion to Intervene
6/28/2011CourtENDORSED ORDER granting in part and denying in part 38 Motion for Expedited Briefing Schedule. Responses on 36 Motion to Intervene shall be filed on or before July 1, 2011. Replies shall be filed on or before July 5, 2011. Signed by Judge Marcia G. Cooke on 6/28/2011.
6/27/2011IntervenorMotion for the Admission of Charles J. Cooper, et al to Appear Pro Hac Vice, Consent to Designation, and Request to Electronically Receive Notices of E-Filing
6/27/2011DefendantNotice of Appearance of Attorney Jason Vail on Behalf of Defendants
6/27/2011CourtAMENDED ORDER setting hearing on 16 Plaintiffs’ Motion for Preliminary Injunction. Motion Hearing set for 7/13/2011, at 10:00 a.m., before Judge Marcia G. Cooke. Signed by Judge Marcia G. Cooke on 6/27/2011.
6/27/2011CourtENDORSED ORDER granting 32 Plaintiffs’ Motion for Hearing. A hearing on Plaintiffs’ Motion for Preliminary Injunction is set for July 13, 2011, at 11:00 a.m. Signed by Judge Marcia G. Cooke on 6/27/2011.
6/27/2011Court*Endorsed Order Setting Expedited Briefing Schedule. Defendants shall file a Response to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Preliminary Injunction on or before July 5, 2011, at 12:00 p.m. Plaintiffs shall file a Reply on or before July 8, 2011. Signed by Judge Marcia G. Cooke on 6/27/2011.
6/27/2011IntervenorProposed Intervenor National Rifle Association’s Motion to Expedite and Incorporated Memorandum of Law
6/27/2011IntervenorProposed Intervenor National Rifle Association’s Corporate Disclosure Statement
6/27/2011IntervenorProposed Intervenor National Rifle Association’s Motion to Intervene and Incorporated Memorandum of Law
6/27/2011IntervenorNotice of Appearance of Proposed Intervenor National Rifle Association
6/24/2011PlaintiffSummons as to State Programs Litigation Office of the Attorney General
6/24/2011PlaintiffSummons as to State Programs Litigation Office of the Attorney General Chief
6/24/2011PlaintiffRequest for Hearing on Plaintiffs’ Motion for a Preliminary Injunction
6/24/2011PlaintiffDeclaration of Dr. Katherine Welty
6/24/2011PlaintiffDeclaration of Dr. June Leland
6/24/2011PlaintiffDeclaration of Dr. Stanley Sack
6/24/2011PlaintiffDeclaration of Dr. Roland Gutierrez
6/24/2011PlaintiffDeclaration of Dr. N. Lawrence Edwards
6/24/2011PlaintiffDeclaration of Dr. Lance Goodman
6/24/2011PlaintiffDeclaration of Dr. Elizabeth King
6/24/2011PlaintiffDeclaration of Dr. Shannon Fox-Levine
6/24/2011PlaintiffDeclaration of Dr. Bernd Wollschlaeger
6/24/2011PlaintiffDeclaration of Dr. Tommy Schechtman
6/24/2011PlaintiffDeclaration of Judith Schaechter, MD
6/24/2011PlaintiffDeclaration of Bruce Manheim, Jr. In Support of Plaintiffs’ Motion for Preliminary Injunction
6/24/2011PlaintiffDeclaration of Dr. Robert Raspa
6/24/2011PlaintiffDeclaration of Dr. Stuart Himmelstein
6/24/2011PlaintiffDeclaration of Dr. Lisa Cosgrove
6/24/2011PlaintiffPlaintiffs’ Motion for a Preliminary Injunction and Accompanying Memorandum of Law
6/24/2011PlaintiffFirst Amended Complaint for Declaratory and Injunctive Relief
6/17/2011CourtOrder Requiring Counsel to Meet and File Joint Scheduling Report and Proposed Order
6/17/2011CourtOrder Referring Case to Magistrate Judge
6/14/2011PlaintiffSummons Return of Service as to Secretary of the State of Florida
6/14/2011PlaintiffSummons Return of Service as to Secretary of Health Care Admin. of the State of Florida
6/14/2011PlaintiffSummons Return of Service as to Surgeon General of the State of Florida
6/10/2011PlaintiffSummons Return of Service as to Florida Department of Health
6/7/2011PlaintiffMotion for the Admission of Bruce Manheim, Douglas Hallward-Dreimeier, et al to Appear Pro Hac Vice
6/7/2011PlaintiffMotion to Appear Pro Hac Vice for Attorney Daniel R. Vice, Consent to Designation, and Request to Electronically Receive Notices of Electronic Filing
6/7/2011PlaintiffMotion to Appear Pro Hac Vice for Attorney Jonathan E. Lowy, Consent to Designation, and Request to Electronically Receive Notices of Electronic Filing
6/7/2011PlaintiffPlaintiffs’ Rule 7.1 Corporate Disclosure Statement and Certificate of Interested Parties
6/6/2011PlaintiffSummons as to Governor Rick Scott
6/6/2011CourtJudge Assignment to Judge Marcia G. Cooke (yha)
6/6/2011PlaintiffComplaint for Declaratory and Injunctive Relief